Best Mascaras

Top Five Drugstore Mascaras

#4 Rimmel Lycra Lash Extender

Excellent consistency, easy to apply, separates, lifts, and actually seemed to curl our lashes. But, while this mascara curls really well, it didn't seem to lengthen as much as the others. The consistency is a little on the thin side but it worked better than Volume Exact to produce a more defined lash. Price: $6.49

Look: separates, lifts, curls lashes

Consistency: smooth but a bit on the thin side