Best Mascaras

Top Five Drugstore Mascaras

#5 CoverGirl Volume Exact

Great flexible rubber brush similar to Define-A-Lash. Provides good coverage and goes on smooth but not particularly lengthening which is why we didn't rate it higher. This is the kind of mascara that needs two coats but it has nice non-clumping qualities at an affordable price, which is why we love it. Price: $6.47

Look: good coverage; not particularly lengthening

Consistency: non-clumping

Brush: flexible, rubber